I am in the process of transferring my currently scattered bits and pieces of writing from all over the web to my blog. Have been meaning to do so for a long time but somehow never got around to it...
While not directly linked to training, it talks about Happiness being the prime factor that leads an individual's engagement with anything--be it business or learning. Creating this happiness as an experience should then be the primary goal if we are to hook learners or customers.
Slide 81 talks about the pillars of Happiness. These can be attributes of training programs as well and such training programs would be the ones most likely to lead to a change in behavior.
Can we create the experience of Flow? ...Refer to slide 129.
Classic question we typically ask as a part of the learner analysis exercise:
1. Who are the learners?
2. What are their demographics and psychographics?
What should we ask instead:
1. What do the learners have to do to be successful?
2. What will improve their status in their organization?
3. What will this training make people better at?
4. What are the learners passionate about?
One way to motivate learners and impact the bottom line of an organization through training is to show how each individual can succeed.
I have cited below a paragraph from the post of particular relevance--about asking questions, the right questions. Disregarding the power of questions or forgetting to raise them and get them clarified can often make or break a course or render it ineffective.
There’s a lot that goes into building a course. Make sure you get access to the right people and resources. Who can review the content? Who can provide assets like logos, images, and documentation? How will you connect with the potential learners? Who will review or pilot the course? What’s the implementation strategy? What type of IT support or technology do you need?
I have added some questions that I have found useful to ask
Who provides the final sign-off? Who is the business client? Whose buy-in do you require to ensure that there is post-rollout support provided to the learners? How will you ensure effective communication throughout the development cycle?
One of my recent experiences reinforced the importance of asking the right questions, asking as many times as required till all expectations are crystal clear to both the client-side stakeholders and the developers of the e-learning program (this includes learning solutions consultant, project managers, instructional designers, visual designers and communicators, illustrators, programmers, integrators, et al).
The mistakes I made, and what did I learn
I was working with an international client who were rolling out e-learning in their organization for the first time. After having familiarized them with the fundamentals of e-learning and having gathered the basic requirements, I got down to collecting the content for the initial modules from one of the SMEs. Being a highly technical course, this SME (Subject Matter Expert) intervention/interaction was of utmost importance. Post this first content-gathering phase, it was time for me to travel back to India.
Mistake #1: I forgot to verify with the stakeholders if the SME who had provided the content would also be the same one reviewing and providing feedback on the storyboards.
Satisfied that I had enough content to start work on the initial modules, I got down to creating the micro-design documents for those modules. Duly referring to the course design document, the audience analysis made, I began drafting the storyboards.
Mistake #2:I did not think of verifying/ratifying the micro-design documents with the clients. This would have saved a lot of heartache for us and panic for the client.
This was an international client and we are working across different time-zones. The primary mode of communication (during the initial phase) was e-mail, whose ineffectiveness I soon found out to my grief.
Mistake #3: I did not leverage the power of the Internet and the various options available for interaction, communication, collaboration--at least till that point. I learned better as time progressed. Again, after coming to grief.
I e-mailed the completed storyboards to the SME for feedback on content logicality, veracity, flow, and other such regular things. What I received in less than 24 hours was nothing short of a panic e-mail (from SMEs different from the one who had provided the content) saying that the content covered was inadequate, lacking in depth, and too generic to be of much use to technicians who needed much more specificity to perform on the job.
I almost had a minor heart attack being clueless as to how this could be the case since the content had been provided by an SME, albeit a different one. This difference was what threw a monkey wrench in what should otherwise have been a fairly straightforward case of review and feedback process.
Insights gleaned
After my panic sub-sided, I realized it was time to get into a more direct conversation with the SMEs. E-mail was just not the answer. The conversation that ensued provided me with the following insights:
The SMEs who had provided the review inputs on the initial storyboards had been unaware of the source of content
The storyboards would be reviewed by multiple SMEs since it was important that all aspects of the tasks be covered
Each SME had their own area of expertise, and all of these had to be brought together in the course
The content was in a state of "high flux" since the product was still being tested and updated
The content provided at the inital stage had changed (vastly) by the time the SMEs got down to reviewing the storyboards
Critical learning
Regular questions we typically ask but which often fail to take care of the finer aspects that go toward making a training program successful:
What is the training needed for?
Is the training truly required? Will this solve the business problem?
What is/are the business need(s) that it aims to fulfill?
What insights has the task analysis provided about performance, hitches faced during on-the-job performance?
What has the learner analysis revealed?
What is the overall desired performance outcome?
Some important questions that remain unasked
Are all communication channels being effectively used (especially important if communicating via Web and across different time-zones)? Can better use be made of tools and applications like Skype, AOL, Webinars, conference calls, video conferencing, Google docs, etc.? (Disregarding or overlooking the effectiveness of these communication platforms in today's super-linked world is like sending snail mail when an e-mail could be sent.)***
How stable is the content? How much of it is likely to change during the development of the training program? (It is safe to assume that in today's world, content will change and change rapidly.)
Which part of the content is least likely to change? (Focus on developing those modules first.)
Who are the SMEs?
Who is the final authority who will provide the sign-off?
Is the reviewer/sign-off authority of the storyboards same as the one who will provide the final sign-off on the produced, functional modules as well? (Any unexpected change during this phase can throw a spanner not only in the development process but will also be a roadblock in the meeting of deadlines and schedules.)
Are all the client-side stakeholders (SMEs, line managers, learning and development team, business managers, technicians, etc.) in synch with each other?
Are they on the same page?
Do they know how their inputs can impact the overall development process and final output?
Are they aware that their respective inputs are important for overall course effectiveness? (While this seems like something that should be handled by the client, as effective consultants, the onus is on us to point out the importance of such interactions and also manage the communication in many cases.)
This is by no means an exhaustive list. I look forward to additions to this list from all...
Some tools I actively used post this panic attack to ensure seamless communication flow
*** During the course of the project, we began to use:
Skype for chats, demos, walk-through, feedback, discussions
AOL messenger for IMs
Dropbox to quickly exchange heavy files and folders
Webinars for walk-through and demos
Conference calls for quick queries and clarifications, discussions, brainstorming
And of course, the ubiquitous e-mail for more formal updates, minutes of meetings, conveying information to all stakeholders-directly or indirectly connected to the development, ensuring all key people have the necessary, critical information for reference and record, and such like
How did these tools help
Apart from ironing out communication gaps and helping the panic to sub-side, these various channels of communication ensured we were in touch with the client at all points during the development cycle. This not only increased their trust in us but also helped us to build that invaluable rapport that made the rest of the project inspiring, fun, "learningful," interactive in the true sense, and increased the chance of the efficacy of the program manifold.
This constant, ongoing dialog also helped to make the SMEs feel involved and valued, lowered their resistance to suggestions, helped them to see our point of view, and created opportunities for healthy exchange of ideas.
I would love to hear your experiences and receive inputs...
As you talk to the client, you realize the training is much needed and has a huge potential—both for you and the client i.e., business wise as well as true value addition.
Here's the real time scenario:
1)The client :
a)Is a valuable one with the possibility of becoming a long-term client
b)Expresses a tentative/possible need for a multimedia training program
c)Also mentions very clearly that budget for this program is minimal to non-existent
d)Requires the program to be attention grabbing and as “innovative” as possible
2)The training program delivery environment is challenging:
a)There would be no PCs for the learners
b)The program would be used to support the trainers in their ILT sessions
c)There would, in most cases, be no conference or seminar rooms for dissemination and training; the possibility of the program being shared in an open-air environment, in broad daylight with thehelp of a simple projector and a screen was very real
d)This, of course, led to a challenge in design, colour usage, font size, on-screen animation, and structure
e)The learner would have no control over the program in terms of being able to stop/play/replay…the trainer would have to gauge the learner’s reaction and carry out the actions as and when required
f)The program needed to have all the features that would attract learners with the psychographics and demographics mentioned below
g)To make things fun, the program was of a highly technical nature
3)The target audience is a very different set from the usual:
a)They have never been exposed to e-learning
b)Have rudimentary to non-existent knowledge of computers
c)Have minimal access to PCs and internet
d)Have low reading skills and poor attention span
e)Probably attending formal training of any kind for the first time
f)The English language could be a bit of a challenge for some
g)Would not be the kind at all to ask questions to clarify doubts
h)Would unquestioningly accept as gospel truth whatever was onscreen
i)Would need to quickly transfer the training to practical work
4)The business need of the program (our analysis):
a)To train mechanics in a country on the product maintenance where the product was being launched for the first time
b)To create a brand presence for the product in the international market
c)To act as support for their advertising campaigns (not yet suggested)
d)To instill confidence in customers of the product that they would get reliable after-sales and repairing services from trained mechanics, if required
e)To ensure trust in the product grows
f)Point b, c, d and e to act as drivers to boost sales in the country of launch
All of the above needs were to be addressed at a minimal cost but the client was an immensely valuable one.
5)What did we do?
a)We sat down
b)We discussed possible solutions that would be cheap enough for the client
c)We discussed solutions that would, most importantly, fulfill the needs mentioned above
d)We discussed solutions that would impact the learners
e)Most importantly, the solution should result in an ROI from the business perspective (point 4 above)
f)It should result in a feasible business deal for us as well
g)It should keep the client coming back for more such programs
6)Results of our brainstorming: (considering all the different parameters mentioned above)
a)The program would need to have a very strong and appealing visual design that could withstand open-air dissemination, support ILT sessions and still be relevant should it be taken on PCs by individuals at any given point
b)Content on screen would need to be minimal and simple
c)The voice over would need to explain the concepts clearly, simply
d)The graphics/images would need to have self explanatory animations, supporting voice over, smooth and easy transitions, few supporting onscreen keywords for emphasis and retention
e)Would have to be self running, yet at a pace that a majority of learners would be able to keep up with
f)Follow sound instructional strategies and structure that would:
i)make logical sense to the learners,
ii)build expectancy thus enabling the learners to predict what would follow helping the assimilation
iii)have a theme across all the topics that is constant (this would again be a support for point ii above)
iv)at no point be a cognitive overload for the learners yet convey all the important technical knowledge
v)enable learners to actually take the knowledge to the field by showing the practical applications (theory would be minimal in such a training program, appearing only to clarify/logically support a practical tip)
7)Addressing the low cost factor: (thought this deserved a separate point of its own as this became our biggest challenge)
a)We identified the constant/common elements across different topics during the content analysis and project scope definition phase
b)Created a structure that would hold true for a majority of the topics, i.e., could be repeated across the topics
c)Decided on the templates and animation flow and other design factors that can be standardized, repeated
d)Created a prototype course and evaluated it for effectiveness in the setting described above with the client’s involvement
e)All of this helped us to create a course design that was quickly implementable, had reusable elements (Learning Object driven) and succeeded in bringing down the cost
8)The final step:
a)We took our solution and analysis to the client
b)Posed our solution and showed the business benefits that could accrue—not only terms of training (that would become much less painful for the trainers) but the consequences of a training well designed and effectively delivered
c)The client was convinced…they will still continue to be penny pinching but we got the project! J
9)Our key learnings:
a)Carry out a very thorough needs analysis and delve into the root cause of the training need
b)Map it to the business and understand the business drivers very very clearly
c)Understand the audience and training environment with absolute clarity
d)NEVER hesitate to ask questions till you have all the information
e)Warn the client UPFRONT that this has to be a combined effort for the program to be successful and allow them to be involed even in the design decisions
f)This way, not only will you get their buy in but also their trust and respect
I would love to know if you have similar experiences and how you have dealt with them…